Skip to content

2023 MMDBL All-Stars

AI-selected: the league has never voted on All-Stars, so these teams were picked from 2023's results by one fixed set of rules. How they were picked.

Season: 2026 · 2025 · 2024 · 2023 · 2022 · 2021 · 2020 #2 · 2020 #1

Bull Durham All-Stars

10 clubs · 25 players

Starting lineup

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CWillson ContrerasMilwaukee334.300.389.48610410+25.9
1BYandy DiazSeattle393.316.405.4535523+14.3
2BLuis ArraezLed league: AVGSan Francisco334.344.386.4202433+13.5
3BJose RamirezSan Francisco404.280.354.507105112+22.1
SSTrea TurnerNY Yankees408.312.353.503124718+23.5
RFMookie BettsChi White Sox395.267.377.524217018+22.8
LFJulio RodriguezChi White Sox323.306.362.515104818+16.2
LFMike TroutToronto334.245.323.56021571+12.6
DHManny MachadoSt. Louis364.290.363.48814507+17.5

Reserves

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CJ.T. RealmutoSt. Louis356.261.317.436134619+12.6
1BPaul GoldschmidtLed league: RBIMilwaukee391.285.366.50018711+12.9
SSNico HoernerChi White Sox352.294.324.40443528+11.0
SSWilly AdamesDetroit225.278.338.4988320+10.7
SSJon BertiLed league: SBSeattle362.263.326.36632939+7.5
CFByron BuxtonLed league: HRChi White Sox325.206.274.49323575+6.8
DHShohei OhtaniLed league: SODetroit299.255.318.51518451+2.4

Pitchers

RolePlayerClubGGSW-LSVIPERAFIPSOValue
SPJoe MusgroveLed league: ERAChicago Cubs22229-50145.11.923.46123+19.9
SPYu DarvishSan Francisco191911-50137.22.483.21147+16.4
SPSandy AlcantaraNY Yankees181810-40137.02.763.18109+14.5
SPSpencer StriderNY Yankees18186-40106.13.222.38160+13.3
SPMiles MikolasLed league: WSan Francisco202012-10147.03.124.8797-1.2
RPEdwin DiazDetroit3908-22251.20.871.9491+14.4
RPDevin WilliamsToronto3503-1449.21.092.2173+12.5
RPHector NerisClub's All-StarBoston2600-4455.02.622.1271+9.5
RPRyan HelsleyLed league: SVChi White Sox3102-12333.02.733.6138+2.8

The Natural All-Stars

10 clubs · 25 players

Starting lineup

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CWilliam ContrerasTexas315.278.349.44410302+15.7
1BFreddie FreemanAtlanta409.276.369.434103213+7.7
2BAndres GimenezPhiladelphia343.323.388.484105222+21.2
3BNolan ArenadoMinnesota397.296.355.55819741+26.9
SSCarlos CorreaTexas404.305.386.45412500+24.2
RFAaron JudgeLed league: AVG, HR, RBIAtlanta417.331.427.72339839+51.4
LFJoc PedersonKansas City309.269.369.48511431+11.3
CFMichael Harris IIAtlanta303.267.310.474136012+10.4
DHJazz Chisholm Jr.Washington285.263.351.534134412+18.2

Reserves

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CWill SmithMinnesota330.246.321.43412411+12.1
SSXander BogaertsLA Angels371.304.361.4377403+16.2
DHYordan AlvarezLA Angels410.277.393.50117650+14.8
CCal RaleighLA Angels237.212.295.51417430+11.3
3BRafael DeversCincinnati356.267.343.42511313+9.6
LFBryce HarperCincinnati323.296.350.48583312+9.4
LFSteven KwanLed league: SBPhiladelphia335.268.377.33812134+4.7

Pitchers

RolePlayerClubGGSW-LSVIPERAFIPSOValue
SPKevin GausmanMinnesota21217-40136.02.582.08151+24.0
SPJeffrey SpringsLed league: ERALA Angels16167-40112.22.082.93122+17.8
SPCorbin BurnesLed league: WWashington +1242411-110167.13.072.96197+16.9
SPJustin VerlanderClub's All-StarLA Dodgers212110-100146.02.473.55153+14.8
SPGerrit ColeLed league: SOMinnesota22228-90148.23.813.80207+1.9
RPDaniel BardLed league: SVPhiladelphia3504-01749.21.452.7656+10.0
RPJ.P. FeyereisenWashington2306-21053.01.872.5956+10.0
RPAlexis DiazMinnesota3402-2351.21.572.9561+9.6
RPFelix BautistaLed league: SVBaltimore3404-01748.11.493.0471+8.9

How the All-Stars were picked

The MMDBL has never voted on All-Stars, so these teams were selected by AI from each season's regular-season results, using one fixed set of rules for every season:

  • Two squads a season, one per league, 25 players each: nine starters (C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, three outfielders and a DH), seven reserves, five starting pitchers and four relievers.
  • Value is runs above an average player, from each season's regular-season results. For hitters: batting (wOBA against the season average), plus steals, plus the standard adjustment for how hard the position is. For pitchers: runs saved against the season's average pitcher, half on ERA and half on FIP (strikeouts, walks and home runs).
  • Starters are the most valuable player at each position (the position he played most; DH if he played the field in fewer than half his games), the three best outfielders, and the best remaining hitter at DH.
  • League leaders in batting average, home runs, RBI, stolen bases, wins, ERA, strikeouts and saves are automatic All-Stars.
  • The rest of the bench (with a second catcher), the rotation and the bullpen are the most valuable players left.
  • Every club gets at least one All-Star, as in MLB: a club left out gets its most valuable player in place of the lowest-valued reserve, starter or reliever.
  • Playing time: hitters need 2 plate appearances per team game, starting pitchers 0.8 innings and relievers 0.25. A player's whole season counts, every club included; one traded between leagues is an All-Star where he played most.

2023 averages: wOBA .307, ERA 3.92. Value is in runs: +10 means about ten runs better than an average player over the same playing time. Badges mark a league leader and a club's only All-Star. Numbers come from the Player Record Book.