The MMDBL has never voted on All-Stars, so these teams were selected by AI from each season's regular-season results, using one fixed set of rules for every season:
Two squads a season, one per league, 25 players each: nine starters (C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, three outfielders and a DH), seven reserves, five starting pitchers and four relievers.
Value is runs above an average player, from each season's regular-season results. For hitters: batting (wOBA against the season average), plus steals, plus the standard adjustment for how hard the position is. For pitchers: runs saved against the season's average pitcher, half on ERA and half on FIP (strikeouts, walks and home runs).
Starters are the most valuable player at each position (the position he played most; DH if he played the field in fewer than half his games), the three best outfielders, and the best remaining hitter at DH.
League leaders in batting average, home runs, RBI, stolen bases, wins, ERA, strikeouts and saves are automatic All-Stars.
The rest of the bench (with a second catcher), the rotation and the bullpen are the most valuable players left.
Every club gets at least one All-Star, as in MLB: a club left out gets its most valuable player in place of the lowest-valued reserve, starter or reliever.
Playing time: hitters need 2 plate appearances per team game, starting pitchers 0.8 innings and relievers 0.25. A player's whole season counts, every club included; one traded between leagues is an All-Star where he played most.
2023 averages: wOBA .307, ERA 3.92. Value is in runs: +10 means about ten runs better than an average player over the same playing time. Badges mark a league leader and a club's only All-Star. Numbers come from the Player Record Book.